Do you think it is fair or right?
By Mommamea
@Mommamea (1215)
United States
December 20, 2006 1:55pm CST
So my husband wanted the new Nintendo WII. Not only for the kids but so we could spend some family time together interacting and he thought it would be fun for when we have friends over as well. I have a problem with the fact that with these being in such demand why people try to profit off them by selling them for ridiculus amounts on Auction sites. How do you feel about products that are bought just for this reason? By them and then resale them immediately. I think their should be a law against this! There are families out there trying to make a living to give their children what they want for Christmas and then we have these jerks that want to sell products for 2 and 3 times what they sell for. Would you purchase these products for higher amounts? Should there be laws against this kind of activities?
10 people like this
69 responses
@zemughul (180)
• France
20 Dec 06
Actually if it's not your job, you don't have the right to buy something with the only aim to sell it with a higher price -or at least in france-. But there's no way you can control it, really. I know many french people who couldn't buy a WII in France, so they bought it in Germany..
2 people like this
@tooblue (143)
• United States
21 Dec 06
I can understand you fustration..I remember when we were tryomg to get an Xbox 360 for my boyfriend and we stood outside like in three different stores waiting while people used thier kids to buy them ( they only allowed one per person, not one per household)..It sucked majorly..and we didnt get one for months later...I saw some 360's go for $1000's of dollars..Triple the retail value...I wish that the stores were more concious towards that..but they are just out to make money
@emarie (5442)
• United States
20 Dec 06
you know what...i wanted to do the same with the PS3...its a good profit, and as long as there are people willing to pay this much for it, then its fine. with sites like eBay it makes it easier. now if the buy like several (which you can't unless you're a dealer) thats wrong. now, these stores and deals are pretty much doing the same thing. they pay a certian amount for the game stations and then sell it at a higher costs which is why some places sell it cheeper then some. there's no real differance. it just depends on how much you want to pay for it. if you're going to outlaw that kind of action, then you will be only allowed to buy directly from nintendo, and you know they don't do that.
2 people like this
@Mommamea (1215)
• United States
21 Dec 06
Thanks Metallion. These stores are not doing the same thing or they would be selling them for what the people on the auctions are. If they can't buy several then how can you see these people listing several on the auctions? Making a profit is okay within limitations. Taking advantage of people is also entirely different. Why some places can sell it cheaper is because of the type of store it is and the quality of the merchandise as well. Not saying you can't get good quality items at a Walmart but you wouldn't go in there to buy fine diamonds either. Thanks for the response. It's good to hear the feed back from all points. Have a Merry Christmas.
@Metallion (2227)
• United States
21 Dec 06
Actually you are wrong, the manufacturers have an agreement with their distributors for a price range they can not go above or below. I'm not a fan of it, but I know people will do it.
1 person likes this
@vipul20044 (5793)
• India
21 Dec 06
Well i know how you must be feeling but then there are less people who go for auctions as they know it will be rather costly
There must be a law to protect people from such hypocrites but tel me if you had an oppurtunity to earn a fortune the same way what would you have had done?
2 people like this
@Mommamea (1215)
• United States
29 Jan 07
Sure I want to earn extra money but I also have my morals. I would not take advantage of others. I agree with allowing them to resell them on auctions and the people can bid as high as they want. I just have a problem with people buying so many at a time and reselling them. How does this give others a fair chance of getting an item if it is bought out before you get to the counter? I think it should be limited when an item is in such high demand.
@emisle (3822)
• Ireland
20 Dec 06
I'd wait until there was more stocked in the shop, i would not be prepared to pay way over the odds for a games console.
And I don't agree with people buying products just to sell them at a higher price, but the same is happening in the housing market.
2 people like this
@Mommamea (1215)
• United States
21 Dec 06
We were prepared to wait until after Christmas if we had to. My husband was willing to sleep in the truck over night but not willing to pay what some of these people are charging. The difference with the housing market is the value of the home and land wouldn't you say? Sure there are alot out there I wouldn't pay that kind of price. I don't like the way the market goes up and down that's for sure. Thanks for the response. Merry Christmas.
@uvbnskoold (499)
• Canada
20 Dec 06
I'm not sure I completely agree with it, but I know where you're coming from. The "laws" of supply and demand make these people see dollar signs in their eyes. They see a high demand and little supply and decide to take advantant of that.
There's nothing wrong with that in itself, but it becomes wrong when they ask outrageous prices for them. There's nothing wrong with asking for $20-40 dollars more than what the purchase price is at a store, but doubling it is just plain low and an obvious attempt to score quick cash preying on the fact that they know that parents want their kids to be happy.
There should be laws in place that limit these people, but nothing that stops it completely. I don't personally agree with it, but just because I don't agree with something, doesn't mean it's totally wrong.
@Mommamea (1215)
• United States
21 Dec 06
I agree with you. Sure if you want to sell it for a little extra then fine but some of these prices are way up there. Have you heard about the ones who are robbing and killing over these things? Wow. What people do for money these days! Are we so money hungry that we can't make a honest living. Thanks for the response. Merry Christmas.
@jenbatres (799)
• United States
20 Dec 06
I don't see anything wrong with this. . .people camped out at the stores to get them, this may be how they make extra cash at the holidays. I would never do it because I don't have that kind of energy. The people who camped out for days for the products need to be compensated, at least they are willing to sell them. If your not willing to pay for it, someone else will.
2 people like this
@Mommamea (1215)
• United States
21 Dec 06
You are correct in saying someone else will. They are doing it. I just can't believe the prices they are paying. There are many jobs available if they are in that much need of extra cash don't you think? And if they have the money to buy extras why do they need the extra cash? But I guess some people will try to take advantage of others when given the chance. Thanks for the response. Merry Christmas.
@micheller (1365)
• United States
20 Dec 06
I would never buy something like that. And yes I think there should be laws to stop this kind of stuff. I actually think there are laws against this, but it isn't taken care of that often.
1 person likes this
@Mommamea (1215)
• United States
21 Dec 06
Good point MKIRBY. I guess I'm not speaking about the ones who have a reserve a bit over the amount they paid for the item and sure include the shipping as well. It's the ones who put the reserve high and are out to take advantage of others. Others do make a bidding war out of it and they are willing to pay outrageous prices for something fine but give the ones who can't a chance as well.
@Mommamea (1215)
• United States
21 Dec 06
Thanks micheller for your response as well. Maybe if the laws were a little more known then it would stop some of the people who are out take advantage of others. I don't know of these laws myself. Not in the United States anyway. Does anyone know about any of these laws? Merry Christmas to you both and thanks for responses.
@mkirby624 (1598)
• United States
21 Dec 06
There may be laws against sellers inflating the price, but there aren't any against buyers bidding outrageously high amounts. On auction sites, the sellers are not inflating prices, people are simply bidding and bidding and bidding until the price skyrockets and it twice as much as the seller paid. This is just great luck for the seller. My neighbor bought a PS3 and put it on ebay for one cent. It was a one day auction, and in one day, it went from one cent to $1400. He didn't screw anyone over, those people screwed themselves over.
2 people like this
@babygrl22004 (238)
• United States
18 Jan 07
People are going to do anything they can to make extra money. I don't necessarily think they should be able to sell items at such a high price but when others are bidding on them then why not make the money. You are not forcing the people to bid so high. If people are dumb enough to spend the money why not be the one making it. Why put a law on what other people are spending if they want to spend it?
@kattinround (84)
• United States
20 Dec 06
well I have points on both sides of this coin, First I do see your point about families wanting to get and give their children what they want for Christmas and that its hard even at regular prices sometimes, especially when they are only making and distributing a certain amounts, that makes it very hard on the working middle class families, but on the other hand if SOME FOOL wants to spend thousands of dollars let him, because the man that is selling it to him might need a little more money then what he has and he is just trying to give his kids a good Christmas as well!
2 people like this
@mikeyr6000le (2123)
• United States
21 Dec 06
No, there should not be any kind of law against this. It's called supply and demand. People do it everyday. Yes the prices they pay for them are outrages but they have the money to waste on that stuff. Children will just have to learn that they won't always get things they want. Some children don't even get the things they need let alone things they want.
Yes there are families out there trying hard to make ends meet to give their kids what they want. There are even more families out there trying to make ends meet just to give kids what they need. If your family needs a Nintendo Wii to have family time I feel sorry for you.
Also to asnwer the question of would I buy one at those high prices? No, I would not. I have much better things to spend my money on. Maybe you could go buy one, sell it for a higher price, then go buy another one and have left over cash.
1 person likes this
@Mommamea (1215)
• United States
21 Dec 06
Well no need to feel sorry for me. I didn't say that is all this family has to do. No my kids don't get everything they want either. They have to work for what they get and they get what they diserve. My husband bought one for the regular price after sitting in his truck all night. Was it right for the store to only sell him one? Sorry that the 4 others behind him would have lost out but he could have sold them one at a good price I'm sure. If that is how my family were to opperate but it isn't. He did not complain. He bought the one my family wanted and went on his merry way. My thoughts on supply and demand if you can afford to pay for 2 of these things in the first place you aren't doing so bad that you need the extra money you are making off others. Sure if you sold items for a little more than you paid for it or to cover some other expense incured fine but it is outrageous to take advantage of those less fortunate than you. Especially when they have 3 or 4 for sale. No need to get in an uproar over a simple discussion my friend. I just posted a question to see what people thought. Thanks for the response though.
@texasclassygal (5305)
• United States
21 Dec 06
It is not fair but it happens all the time, even with such things as hotel rooms. I lived in a city almost 10 years ago that went through a horrible hurricane when our home electricity was wiped out for 3 weeks we tried to get a room down the road, a normal $69.99 room was $300.00 a night with this storm. It is wrong and the government should step in and do something about it.
1 person likes this
@coolcager (496)
• Costa Rica
20 Dec 06
its very natural its a law of supply and demands hehe. many people want it but not everybody can buy it. they raise the price because some people really do want it. Why not buy PS3 its way more better i think. I have Xbox 360 and its good enough.
@ProfSlughorn (93)
• France
21 Dec 06
I think that selling things for 2 or 3 times more than it is should be allowed, but if you're not happy with it then just try to get it from a normal store, I tried the Wii and didn't think much of it. If you really can't get the Wii apart from online overpriced, the n try the Xbox 360
2 people like this
@kstanley7 (1171)
•
30 Dec 06
No I would not purchase one of these products for a higher amount, but with regards to the high amount online, especially with ebay, its not the seller who has set the price, but everyone keeps bidding, so the price is increased only due to the buyers who feel the need to get one.
1 person likes this
@Lydia1901 (16351)
• United States
29 Dec 06
Well, that's what you call business. Those people that are doing that, are doing it because it's their job and that's how they make a living. The prices are too much though, and I think that's wrong to do that to other people that are trying to get this for their children. I wouldn't purchase it for a very expensive price either, I'd rather buy it at the store with the original price.
@ljmc24 (413)
• United States
21 Dec 06
If I can get my hands on something that someone else sees as much more valuable then I will definitely resale it for a profit. I see the problem with this is in the companies who purposely release a limited amount of this product and then the parents who will actually pay the scalpers the crazy amount just so their kids can have it. It teaches kids nothing but to be greedy.
1 person likes this
@superbusiness72 (9)
• United States
30 Dec 06
That isn;t fair for the families that are trying to get a nice gift for the kids. I think that they should have a law against that. I think it is crazy to charge so much around a holiday.
1 person likes this
@Mikail23214 (42)
• Canada
21 Dec 06
Sorry to say but theres nothing you can do about this, there wouldnt be a law for it, because people can argue that they need to pay rent so they sell it to make profit, etc, maybe there making a living to, you just never know, the world works in a way to always make profit, right now your on a site to make money right? yeh, i bet if there was a way you can make even more you would want it right, well people want more to so i guess thats how they do it, by the way, Nintendo Wii is sold out everywhere! so maybe people just want to sell it for alot of money and then when it comes back in stores, they buy it again but with more games and extra controller, and they have enough money because they made profit.
1 person likes this
@wiiwillman (30)
• Canada
4 Jan 07
Well this is a tough decision, and I have mixed opinins on the matter. Yes. it's just nuts how people are paying thousands, but people will do that for Xmas, right? However, it is good profit.
1 person likes this