Disturbing trend?
By BunGirl
@BunGirl (2638)
United States
January 30, 2007 12:33pm CST
I've seen more and more copy-and-pasted posts lately. People who should know better (they've been here long enough!) are simply searching for interesting news on the internet and copying it into their discussions. I just want to make sure everyone knows that this is against the rules here at myLot. Those articles are copyrighted to their original authors. If you'd like to tell people about the article, just post the link and then paraphrase it IN YOUR OWN WORDS. Please don't assume that no one will notice when you copy and paste. It's blatantly obvious to anyone who pays attention.
15 people like this
31 responses
@brokentia (10389)
• United States
31 Jan 07
I could not agree with you more!!! I was upset just yesterday because I ran into a discussion that was started and it seemed like a copy and paste article. So, I searched it and found that it was word for word from a health website. The title of the article was not even changed!
The person that wrote that article took the time to research the subject and put it into words. I would think that one would at least give a summary and then tell the reader that if they wanted more information or to read the full article, they give a link to that article.
But then I see these people do not even give a reference to the article. It is then posted as if it is their own words. And that is called plagiarism!!!
Well, my friends, it is against myLot guidelines and I hope that if you run into something like this, you would report it. Because there are people like us that do the real work and read the article and put into our own words!
It is not fair to the writer being plagiarized and not fair to others that work hard on myLot.
5 people like this
@re08dz (1941)
• Australia
31 Jan 07
As the poster above said, unfortunately it's not a new trend - I know not long after I joined, I was amazed at how often I would come across an article that had been copied from another site with no credit given to the original author. (Of course even if credit is given I don't think people should just paste other people's words and then expect monetary credit for it, even if they have provided the attached author credit)
The thing is, is that not only is it against myLot's rules it's also a breach of copyright and could get the poster in a great deal of trouble (finacial as well as legal). I know there has been times when I spent the majority of my time on this site reporting those I came across. I have several articles scattered around the internet on a variety of different subjects and I know I would be devastated if I discovered someone basically claiming my words as their own.
I will admit that I haven't come across any recently and I thought that some of the changes (the no copy/paste rule etc) might have made a difference. But I gather by this that unless they are old discussions that have yet to be deleted, once again people have found a way around the restriction.
All I can suggest is that we all keep reporting them and hopefully sooner or later people will get the idea that it's just not worth it - at least until the next bunch of would be cheaters come along.
@JC1969 (1224)
• United States
31 Jan 07
Several mylot friends, and I discovered that there were still members that had under 500 rating and were copy and pasting. We found out that there is another browser that is used other than IE, that allows you to bypass the 'no copy and paste till 500' feature. Also, many of those members that were already doing this, when that new rule went into play, already had well over 500 rating; so, it did nothing to prevent this type of scamming.
1 person likes this
@BunGirl (2638)
• United States
31 Jan 07
What's more is that not only could the person doing the copying get in trouble, but myLot could too. Remember when myspace was the target of a lawsuit because of music sharing that was going on on their site? The last thing I want to see is this website shut down because of a few people who can't be bothered to write their own content.
1 person likes this
@JC1969 (1224)
• United States
31 Jan 07
This isn't a new trend though, it's been going on since the conception of Mylot. I blame it on the easy joining process. They take just anyone, and they have no real way of keeping up and monitoring the integrity and ethics of the members that join. They depend on all of us to police and monitor their site, but all that does is swamp them with numerous 'abuse reports' that they take weeks and weeks to go through before they get a chance to remove the person. And, what's the good of removing the person? They just come back with a new and different name, but same old game.
I've suggested a few times to Mylot that they give us the a blocking feature and a 'red flagging feature'. This way if we see someone who cheats and scams here, we can block them, report them, and then also 'red flag' them. The 'red flag' would also appear next to their discussion and this will tell other members to not even bother going there and responding. When these members see that they aren't getting responses, other than from their scammer friends, they might just go away. It would also help mylot moderate their own site. They can go to these flagged discussions and they too can check out the abuse with ease, and possibly even catch all the other scammers in that discussion--because they all seem to flock together.
I no longer want to start discussions here, because I don't want some cheater to come along and plagiarize my words, and earn off of what I write.
3 people like this
@BunGirl (2638)
• United States
31 Jan 07
The problem with allowing users to red flag or block people is that some folks will use it for the wrong reasons. (IE "I don't agree with this person so I'm flagging them")
I think not allowing copy and paste until 500 posts was a huge step in the right direction though. This way if they are booted and they want to create another username and do it again, they have to wait until they get to 500.
3 people like this
@BunGirl (2638)
• United States
31 Jan 07
Oh, believe me, I know that people are already abusing the ratings system. But what I'm saying is how much more damage they could do if they could block or red flag people.
I don't know what the solution is, but your signup procedure sounds like a good place to start. Of course, less people on the site would cut back on the revenue, so I doubt that will happen anytime soon.
1 person likes this
@MissGia (955)
• United States
31 Jan 07
i saw someone copy and paste someones exact words the other day... i noticed it becuase 1.i had already replied to the same discussion..and below where it showed related dicussions you could see the same words in a like discussion.. I ofcourse did what every mylotian who sees this activity should do.. reported it :)
I dont understand why people just cant type themselves..only time i copy and paste is Website links.
3 people like this
@rahuliet2008 (5)
• India
31 Jan 07
yes true it really creating fake thing in my lot they can post maxm no of discussion
1 person likes this
@Wanderlaugh (1622)
• Australia
31 Jan 07
Some of the things I've seen are literal ripoffs of whole articles from websites. One of them, from memory, still had the AP heading. Others were bulk posts, several at a time, pretty conspicuous.
I searched one, and it was absolutely verbatim from several news sites. You can spot the style, easily, and if the person's posts are otherwise netbabble, you can see a difference even more easily. It's hard to pretend a writing style.
Suggest just don't reply, and report abuse. If we wanted to read newspapers, we can do it ourselves.
@kgwat70 (13387)
• United States
31 Jan 07
It is called plagiarism and has been going on for a while but seems to be getting worse like mentioned above. People will do anything to make extra money, even stealing the work from other members here or from the authors of other websites. We should always include a link to the site we got the information from.
2 people like this
@sureshmoe (974)
• India
31 Jan 07
Before 2 months, i was done one or two discuusions by copy and paste from mylot. After that i think myself that why am i do like this? I have sense of thinking....now i avoid that totally and do myself...
2 people like this
@estherlou (5015)
• United States
6 Feb 07
I thought the copy and past rule was for copying other peoples posts or discussions and using them as your own. I didn't think it pertained to articles off the internet. And what's wrong with copying and pasting part of an article if you give the link?
1 person likes this
@suedarr (2382)
• Canada
31 Jan 07
What I tend to do if I find an interesting item from the news is to quote a snippet then add a source link. Either underneath or above I will then share my thoughts on that bit of news. I tend to post obscure stuff or local news that others might not have heard about. I believe that if credit is given and it is not just the news story and nothing else it should be ok.
1 person likes this
@wesderby (178)
• United States
30 Jan 07
Great point...Not only would pasting the link be the right thing to do legally and in keeping with Mylot's terms and such, but it would also give people the option of deciding for themselves whether or not they actually want to read the article that's being referenced. If you think about it, anyone who can access Mylot obviously has access to the internet, and can access other websites, so a link to the story you want to discuss is not only the right thing to do, it's the most logical thing to do.
3 people like this
@pradesh13 (287)
• India
31 Jan 07
This is really true.we should follow the Rules and the Regulations of the website. If you want to earn money you should utilise the skills and post so that others are benefited. It should be a problem solving exercise for all; not a problem creating exercise.
@VAnnasamy (426)
• India
31 Jan 07
I copy my own 'stuff' and paste it here. This helps me to be more creative. Learning, unlearning, learning are the process suited for excellence.
You get some IDEAS and if you follow them, after some time, you never know, same would become IDEALS.
-va-
1 person likes this
@BunGirl (2638)
• United States
31 Jan 07
If by "my own 'stuff'" you mean things you personally have written, that's fine. As long as you own the rights to your work, you can post it anywhere you'd like. What I'm referring to is people who copy news articles or wikipedia pages or whatever and post it here. Unless they are the authors of the piece, they have no right to post it as if it's their own.
1 person likes this
@VAnnasamy (426)
• India
6 Feb 07
My own 'stuff' means my own ideas that come from my brain and I paste it here for interaction. Creativity is the key word.
1 person likes this
@igotapluscom (9)
• Canada
31 Jan 07
This is very disappointing to read as a new subscriber. I'm actually here to see if i can get a intellectual conversation.
1 person likes this
@wmg2006 (5381)
• United States
31 Jan 07
I haven't noticed this at all. I guess some people just don't have any thought left and they are reading something interesting and want to share it. I know it is the lazy way out to just copy and paste. They don't usually get my attention unless they are saying something about the article per se.
@chaitrakrishnan (181)
• India
31 Jan 07
Yeah you are right.. i have seen many topics like that..
but the mylot system has introduced a new system like not allowing the members to copy paste the response. but many topics related to personnel problems and who for suggestions there no one can copy paste the response from a blog or from a website they have to type the response. If the response is irrelevant to the topic then one can decide its a scam..
@BunGirl (2638)
• United States
31 Jan 07
Actually, the rules you're referring to only apply to those with less than 500 posts. If you have more than 500 you can use the copy and paste function all you want. This is so we can post links and short quotes without having to type them out, but many people are abusing this and pasting entire articles.
@palpalsky (899)
• United States
20 Mar 07
well how long can do such things ..will they get content for that ..remember we here come to enjoy ..not to just run in some race
1 person likes this