GRILLING: do you use charcoal or do you use gas?

Philippines
May 29, 2008 3:28am CST
i never tried grilling on gas, and i want to know the difference. i watched a lot of cooking shows that do some grilling and most of them use gas for grilling. i want also to have or to buy one of those gas for grilling but i want to know the difference between grilling on gas and grilling on charcoal. does it taste the same? is it faster to grill on gas or just the same?
4 people like this
27 responses
@reejane (293)
• Philippines
3 Jul 08
I'm used to grilling using charcoal. Haven' tried using a gas so I have no idea what's the difference when you cooked something on it.
• Philippines
6 Jul 08
thanks for the response reejane. i too have no experience yet thats why i satrted this discusion. just read around and you can learn a lot from the myloters who responded here. i learned a lot hope you do too.
2 people like this
@irishmist (3814)
• United States
24 Jun 08
It's a charcoal grill for me, I wouldn't use anything else. I love the smokey flavor from charcaol, now thats a real BBQ!
1 person likes this
• Philippines
24 Jun 08
hi five there for your response irish, but during rainy season even i am craving for grilled foods i can not have one because charcoal grilling is for outdoors. well i can still grill indoors if it is raining. thanks a lot for the response
2 people like this
@schulzie (4061)
• United States
11 Jun 08
I prefer to grill on gas, but my husband prefers charcoal. I have never used charcoal but I think it is a lot more work. With gas or propane you just turn it on and it's ready to go. It is so convenient and clean tasting. I love grilling on my propane grill! :D
• Philippines
19 Jun 08
well thats nice, you can get the best of both worlds. eating something grilled on charcoal and grilled in something that is grilled on gas. you post your view about gas grilling very well and thanks a lot for that
1 person likes this
@snowy22315 (178806)
• United States
2 Jun 08
I always use my gas grill. I havent had anything on a charcoal grill for years. I know some people swear by charcoal and would never use gas, but the taste of something grilled on a charcoal grill is not worth the problem of dealing with the charcoal.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
8 Jun 08
you have a good point and you dont have to wait that long for grilling on charcoal needs to be started earlier for it eats more time than grilling on gas. thanks for the input there snowy. hi 5
1 person likes this
@rrdj71 (696)
• United States
8 Jun 08
IT probably is faster to grill with gas however, you can't beat the wonderful smoky taste of charcoal. If you don't use charcoal to me it kind of defeats the purpose of a good grilling. Plus, gas is more expensive anyway.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
8 Jun 08
i like how you said that "if you don't use charcoal it kind of defeats the purpose of a good grilling" and that is one of the good points that i have here at this discussion. thanks for that
1 person likes this
• Philippines
19 Jun 08
I prefer grilling on charcoal. In my own opinion, it's tastier that way. It brings out the natural way. But just don't overcook it. It would definitely not taste good!! ;)
• Philippines
19 Jun 08
yes, who would like to have a over grilled food. it taste bitter already when it is over cooked. i agree with you that charcoal grill brings out the natural taste of the food. what are oyur favorite food to put on the grill? i love pork and chicken.
2 people like this
@vanities (11395)
• Davao, Philippines
1 Jun 08
right now im using charcoal,,and its alright but messy...and im planning to buy on the electric grill thing with cover on it,,,very convenient and less smoke i guess...i dont know yet since i havent try it..
• Philippines
8 Jun 08
that is the reason why i want to buy a gas grill for the convinience and less smoke. my wife has asthma but we both love barbeque. thats the reason why i started this discussion to help me decide. thanks a lot for the response
1 person likes this
@karlag (61)
• United States
2 Jun 08
I use gas. You can get grilling chips that will flavor the food. There are hickory chips that give the food a nice flavor. You can get chips marinated in sherry, or you can sprinkle the hot lava rocks with lemon or orange peels for a citrusy flavor. I prefer the gas because I never seem to get the right amount of charcoal to finish all of the food.
@krebstar5 (1266)
• United States
29 May 08
Grilling with gas can be a lot faster. You don't have to worry about taking the time to light the coals and wait for them to heat up. You pretty much light the gas and go. It's also a lot cleaner in that you don't have to clean up the ashes that the coals can leave behind. That being said, gas doesn't taste the same to me as charcoal does. I prefer an all natural carcoal that is made from wood. This gives the food a really nice smoky and sometimes woody flavor. Yes, it means that things can take a bit longer and the coal I like can be hard to find...but I really think that it is worth it.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
2 Jun 08
yes i agree, and most of the responses here are the same as yours. most of us would rather choose old fashion than the high tech ones but doesnt give the taste that we are used to. thanks a lot for the response. cheers
1 person likes this
@luvstochat (6907)
• United States
29 May 08
I don't use either. I have a Traeger grill that you use pellets to cook with. I will never use a gas or charcoal grill again after tasting food that comes off of a Trager grill. We use pellets that are flavored like mesqutie. I need to fire up the grill it sounds good.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
8 Jun 08
wow i never heard of that before. what does it looks like? is it only available on where you are? you are the only one i heard of that here at my discussion. i hope something like that is available also here on our country. thanks a lot for the response
1 person likes this
• United States
2 Jun 08
We used to have a propane grill. It was a lot faster to get it up and running when we wanted to grill something. With coals, we have to wait a while for them to be ready and sometimes it's a pain to keep them going at first. So maybe the advantage of gas is mainly its convenience. When our propane grill broke, we used a little charcoal one for a while and I couldn't believe the difference in the taste of our food. The charcoal grilling gave it a smokier and more flavorful taste. When we replace the grill, I think I'll stick with a charcoal one or maybe just build a nice firepit.
• Philippines
8 Jun 08
hey that is a good idea make yourself or build a nice firepit. i cant do that for we are only renting in a apartment. most of you guys really enjoyed grilling on charcoal even it is messy and the waiting is much longer. most of you who responded loves the taste of w=food when grilled on charcoal.
1 person likes this
@roi452 (232)
• Philippines
30 May 08
I never tried using gas grilling myself, but i prefer charcoal grilled because it tastes better, maybe because of the charcoal and the smoke makes the flavour unique and delicious. Another thing is that charcoal grilling a lot less expensive than gas grilling.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
8 Jun 08
right you are there roi, there is something or the charcoal has an effect to the food that we are grilling and it taste and smell inviting and less expensive too just like you said. thanks a lot for the response
1 person likes this
@thedaddym (1731)
• United States
31 May 08
We used to use charcoal, but now we have a gas grill. It is a lot easier to use that is for sure. We still have some pieces of charcoal in the gas grill though. I really enjoy grilling.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
19 Jun 08
me and my wife enjoys grilling too, we patiently wait for the food to be cooked while smelling the rich flavor and aroma while grilling. i think i will consider to buy the one so we can still grill even when it is raining. thanks a lot for the response
1 person likes this
• Mauritius
29 May 08
I use gas...But i think the taste differ for charcoal, i think the taste is better for charcoal but i like both. But frankly speaking, charcoal is really very economic.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
8 Jun 08
yes charcoal is very economic. in the kind of life we have right now we need to start to practise living frugal. thanks ofr the input and thanks very much for giving time to respond on my discussion.
1 person likes this
@magikrose (5429)
• United States
29 May 08
It is faster too cook on gas because you dont have to wait for the coals to heat up but for me personally I prefer to cook with coal. I just think it tasts better to me. My husband wants to buy a gas grill and I keep stoping him cause it is expensive where charcoal is not as expensive.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
1 Jun 08
i too want to buy a gas grill but i am still taking the survey. my wife has asthma and when we are trying to wait for the coal to heat it gives a lot of smoke. i just want to buy a gas grill to lessen the smoke but if the taste of the barbeque will be affected with the taste then i will not buy a gas grill.
2 people like this
@raijin (10345)
• Philippines
29 May 08
It is charcoal that I still use, I like outdoor cooking and I enjoy doing that whenever possible. I never really tried using gas when doing this, I can't find any thrill and excitement in it. Sometimes, I just light it up then place the food that I want to grill on top. As I could still remember, me and my uncles did this whenever there are fresh fish harvested on a nearby fishpond. It was late night and we are still drinking, one of my uncle lit up some coconut husks and some of their dried shells then placed the fish on top of the ember. One of the memorable outdoor experiences I have ever had, I missed doing that too.
• Philippines
1 Jun 08
i love outdoor cooking too. when my wife and i are still dating we most likely to go on dates at a park or at a swimming resort and cook barbeque. my wife loves all kinds of food that is cooked on the grill. she is good on marinating too. now that we have a two year old son we still do outdoor cooking but not as often as when we dont have a child yet. my son loves eating barbeque too.
3 people like this
@snowy22315 (178806)
• United States
29 May 08
We used to barbecue with charcoal but now use gas. The problem with charcoal is it takes so long and you are always fighting with the charcoal. Sometimes it's lit sometimes it''s not extra. I like the taste of charcola better but gas is good also.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
1 Jun 08
oh yes the battle on charcoal for some charcoal are not that easy to heat up. it is very tiring to wait for a charcoal to heat up. i am still weighting the prons and cons of having a gas grill. thanks a lot for the response
2 people like this
@mayka123 (16605)
• India
29 May 08
Have tasted food grilled on gas buthave never tried it myself. I grill on charcoal because the food tastes better that way!
1 person likes this
• Philippines
31 May 08
to tell you frankly i dont know the difference of gas grilled and charcoal grilled. i dont know when i eat out if they use gas or charcoal for grilling so i dont know the diffrence. thanks a lot for the response
2 people like this
@roxanne271 (2034)
• Trinidad And Tobago
29 May 08
My dad and I use coals for all our grilling or BBQ's. I have never used gas to grill before but I have heard that it doesn't have that nice smoky flavour that comes with the use of coals.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
1 Jun 08
thanks for the response roxanne. yes most of the response here are in favor of charcoal grilling than gas. i think when it comes to grilling everybody loves the old fashion way. for it taste much better the grilling on gas.
2 people like this
@excellence7 (3655)
• Mauritius
29 May 08
I use gas..but I still think that charcoal is more economic and safer to use. I think the taste differs, I like both the taste when cooked on charcoal or gas.
1 person likes this
• Philippines
1 Jun 08
so if you will choose one what would you rather use? grilling with gas or grilling using charcoal? charcoal is economic but i think gas grills faster. maybe thats the reason why they use gas on restaurant for they can grill it faster.
2 people like this