Any suggestions for what to put in a 5gal fish tank?
By rdolphingirl
@rdolphingirl (361)
United States
January 20, 2007 2:13pm CST
I am not new to the world of keeping fish, I haven't had a tank up for awhile now though. I have a 5gal tank with all the stuff to set it up (freshwater) and am wanting to put a male Beta in it, and a few other fish. Was wondering if anyone here had any suggestions as to what else would be good, and work well in that limited space? Also any live plants that would work well in the small space?My kids and I really like color, but not the fake ones (dyed ones). Most likely going for a blue/green/white kinda combo in the Beta.
4 people like this
9 responses
@Signal20 (2281)
• United States
22 Jan 07
Betta would be good. Pobably appreciate to be out of the little cup he's in. Don't do the guppies. The fantail on the guppies would probably cause the betta to attack them.
That's really kinda small for any more fish. I'd go with the betta, maybe 2 African dwarf frogs, couple ghost shrimp(they don't last long though) for cleaners, and how about eventually a snail for the algae when that starts up? Plants, may be kinda hard to keep, but try some java fern. That's pretty hardy.
Now, the million dollar question, you know about cycling the tank first right? Bettas are not good fish to start off cycling a tank, too delicate. If it's got a filter and all, you won't be changing out all the water like you normally do for bettas. I'd recommend doing a fishless cycle. Try going to about.com and do a search for fishless aquarium cycling. It's easy to do, just takes a few weeks.
4 people like this
@rdolphingirl (361)
• United States
22 Jan 07
I have done tanks before , so I know to cycle it first (my kids will bug me the whole time I bet). I do have a filter for it and know to set it up a week or two before getting fish. My local pet store will test water for me and I can get it right that way. They also sell RO water and thats what I plan to be putting in it as the tap water where I live has a very high PH level (and my purifier has a high nitrate level LOL). I will not be getting the Betta til I get the rest all set up and running good. He will be the biggest thing in there so needs to go in last. Thanks for reminding me about the ghost shrimp though, they are cute and do help clean. As for Bettas attacking guppies, I have kept them together before and find that as long as they have plants and room they seem to do fine. Thanks for the recommend on the java fern I will check that out. I may well wait a month or two to do this, I checked out the little ones suggested by skittles in my first answer and they can only be ordered, but I like them and they sound easy to keep. Thanks so much for your input here though! :)
2 people like this
@rjbass (1422)
• United States
24 Jan 07
I thought I'd jump in here and suggest a couple of fish for your 5 gallon tank.
Currently I have a ten gallon with 2 neon tetras, a silver dollar, and a pencil fish. My 3 kids who are all under the age of 6 love watching and feeding them.
But, my suggestion for your tank would be to get a couple of freshwater dwarf puffer fish. They are cute and my kids loved them when we had them. And when taken care of they will live for years.
3 people like this
@rdolphingirl (361)
• United States
25 Jan 07
Hmm, I have a couple suggestions for you ... those tetras, need more then two because they are supossed to school (ie min. of 4-5 in a tank) and that pencil fish, shouldn't be in a 10gal at all, it should have more room.
I appreciate your suggestion, but those take more time and work then I want to put into fish right now. They are cute little buggers though!
1 person likes this
@adams03605 (436)
• United States
24 Jan 07
I am in the same boat as you are. My daughter has a 10 gallon tank with just a betta in it and she wants more fish. I had it set up for the baby platties that I was having while my big tank had a puffer in it- he likes the babies for snacks- but the puffer is gone, so I have my tank back and now she wants more fish.
I told to her to find/choose small fish that will stay small. Any of the platties, tetras and those sorts will not get very big. So they won't outgrow the tank in a year. I just bought some glass tetras and painted tetras for my big tank. They look awesome under the light and really stand out in the big tank. There is a huge variety in the tetra family that can really make some very nice looking fish.
So I guess my suggestion would be to go for some sort of tetra. They are a great little fish and even in a small tank you could have half a dozen without them being over crowded.
Good luck to you and enjoy whatever you choose!
3 people like this
@rdolphingirl (361)
• United States
24 Jan 07
Hmm ... I forgot about the glass tetras ... they are pretty cool looking. Thanks for your suggestions! Best to you with your tanks too.
3 people like this
@skittles46 (388)
• United States
20 Jan 07
Several things come to mind here. 5 gallons is plenty of room for a Betta to really enjoy! You could also get a trio of guppies, but be prepared to deal with babies. It would probably work well to put a trio of guppies, then a Betta as the Betta would enjoy taking care of the baby problem :)
My other suggestion is a tiny livebearer that goes by the name of Heterandria formosa, or hets. They can be kept in as little as 1 gallon, and would be a great combination with something larger as well, possible a single gourami or something with a lot of color to stand out :).
I also have a personal favorite in the white cloud mountain minnows, they have some color, and are very easy to keep. They could also be kept with a Betta as well.
@rdolphingirl (361)
• United States
21 Jan 07
I had thought about guppies. But, I have had them before and ended up with a TON of them from them breeding so I know about babies. I will check out the other two you mentioned though. I want to let my kids at least help pick out what I get too. Thanks for your suggestions!
1 person likes this
@uath13 (8192)
• United States
25 Jan 07
I used to be a breeder for some of the local stores.
I have to warn you about putting the betta with anything else colorful or with large fins. Bettas aren't known for their intelegence and will attack anything they think might be another male betta including a female. Thats why their usually doomed to their solitary existance.
If you like the look of the long fins I'd recomend lyretail swords. Their social and have very long flowing fins much like the betta. Some breeders have even managed to add new colors to them by crossbreeding them with plattys. I even managed a few sunbirst lyretail swords and mickey mouse lyretails.
I really just wanted to stress the point about the betta though. It could be very upsetting to start the new tank and the next day the kids find that the betta has gone homicidal.
1 person likes this
@Signal20 (2281)
• United States
1 Feb 07
I don't think he was being nasty, his info is pretty accurate. There's always the exception to the rule. What it comes down to is the personality of the fish. I've had some that wouldn't get along with anything, and others that would. But, usually it's recommended not to put them with fish that have colorful/fancy tails. Yes, they may not attack and only nip fins and tails, but that's stressful to the other fish that are being attacked-or even if it's the betta being attacked, and could cause fin/tail rot amongst other diseases/infections. A 5 gallon is a small tank, and when you factor in substrate, decorations, plants, etc. it's not really a 5 gallon tank anymore. So that limits the amount of fish even more with trying to balance & keep the tank healthy. If you do go with more fish, I'd stick with the smaller fish, like you said you liked in the first post.
1 person likes this
@skittles46 (388)
• United States
26 Jan 07
Not trying to argue here, but the betta thing seems to be a great controversy. I have successfully put a betta in several community tanks, including with male guppies and swordtails.
Just a note on the swordtails, they don't belong in anything less than a 20 gallon unless you're going to only keep one. They get up to 3 inches long, and need around 4 gallons a piece. They are a lot of fun in a bigger tank though.
1 person likes this
@rdolphingirl (361)
• United States
1 Feb 07
OK ... number one here ... I have had numerous Betta's ... they do NOT attack much ... they do tend to pick at tails and fins on other stuff though. I was not asking for advice about the Betta ... but for advice on OTHER stuff that WOULD go well in a small tank with one. Also I know better then to put the Betta in first. If you know as much as you seem to infer that you do you would know that too. There is NO good reason to "doom" them to a solitary existence !
P.S. An intelligent thing for you might be a spell checker. The Goggle toolbar has one built in that will check text in any boxes you have typed into.
@blacktiger63 (85)
• United States
24 Jan 07
Try not to overstock the tank. I would get a beta only or get two or three guppies. As for plants maybe some dwarf anubias would work if the tank is well lighted.
2 people like this
@rdolphingirl (361)
• United States
21 Jan 07
If you can't contribute to the conversation, why are you posting? Have you read the rules here?
4 people like this
@rdolphingirl (361)
• United States
21 Jan 07
Excuse me?
Who do you think you are to tell me what is a "worthy" topic? Do you own this site? Do you work for this site? Do you have any authority here at all? This reply is not "worthy". If you can't add to the conversation please don't post on my questions. Its no wonder you have a low ranking.
3 people like this
@rdolphingirl (361)
• United States
22 Jan 07
LOL , kinda what I was thinking yea ... really just not a helpful post ;)
3 people like this
@mdzafaruddin (879)
• India
23 Jan 07
put some stones , plants, a oxygen stone , and few fishes that colourful ones that will be the ideal for ur tank
1 person likes this
@rdolphingirl (361)
• United States
23 Jan 07
Did you read my whole question?
Or did you just not understand it?
I have the whole set up, I am just looking for suggestions of WHAT KIND of fish would be good in that size tank, with a male Betta.... as I stated I am NOT new to keeping fish. I was not asking what I need to start it. I was only asking for suggestion on WHAT KIND of fish would be good.
2 people like this