Orphan discussions..

India
December 28, 2012 1:08am CST
Have you noticed, there are discussions initiated by myLot members but after initiating that discussion s/he has not even replied once. I don't understand why people initiate such discussion if they don't have interest in responding back to comments in that discussion. (Though I'm not saying one should reply to all the comments in the discussion) What do you feel for such discussions? Have you ever initiated any discussion where you didn't respond even once? I'm not sure if I've named it correctly but I would say, these are orphan discussions that have got no one to take care of.
7 people like this
19 responses
• Valdosta, Georgia
29 Dec 12
I try to respond to my discussions. Sometimes life gets in the way but I come back and answer them as soon as I have the time. And if someone comes in the discussion way after the fact it might take me a while to get to them because by then I have new discussions going on too. But... I don't start a discussion and never answer anyone. That is rude to do... I don't like how some people don't respond to anyone on their discussion and I also don't like the ones that only respond to CERTAIN people on their discussions... We all have an opinion so no one should just be skipped over like they do not even matter.
3 people like this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
29 Dec 12
hi LovingMyBabies I hate that too when I am bypassede and severalo others and just a few get comments like the re st of ours were just trash.thats re ally sort of mean I think.
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
15 Jan 13
dollar how come at my age I so manage to comment back to all responses that you younger people with more energy have to leave some uncommented on as thats like walking away when someone talks to you as they do not know if you cannot think of something to say they just feel you did not like their response. I just remark on their response as all of us have some worth whether you want t o believe that or not.
• India
29 Dec 12
@LovingMyBabies: Yes, that's true, sometimes if I'm busy with my daily routine, I might get delayed but I certainly try my best to respond to all the comments in my discussions but sometimes, there could be comment where I've no idea what to reply, I rather prefer not to respond to that comment instead of hurting someone with my comment. @Hately: Personally, I never skip any good comments in my discussion and at the same time, it's not an easy thing for me to initiate a discussion, until it's very important topic that I feel should be discussed, I don't initiate the discussion.
1 person likes this
@Hence27 (450)
• India
28 Dec 12
Discussions means you have to comment back to your discussions and they will comment back to yours.In this way a discussion continue. And mylot is a discussion site.So if we start any discussions,then it becomes our responsibility to comment back to our discussions.If we don't have time for it,then we can postpone it for next day.
3 people like this
• India
28 Dec 12
Exactly, that's what I think, if I've an urge of initiating a discussion, I should be ready to share my opinion because it was my initiative to ask people to share their opinion on that topic but I don't know why there are discussions where you see people just adding their comments and nobody is there to reply back to those comments.
1 person likes this
• India
28 Dec 12
That's right, we come to myLot mainly for adding comments, let it be for discussing something or just earning money. In either case, it's always easy to add comments to your own discussion which you have initiated with interest rather than adding one or two comments here or there in some discussion. May be some people feel, if the number in front of the user name doesn't increase, they won't get paid. That's why they don't respond in one discussion more than once.
1 person likes this
@Hence27 (450)
• India
28 Dec 12
Yes,sometimes it happens.But if we start discussions,then we should add comments to our discussions.But it's our responsibility.We can't think about others what they do.If we are here in mylot,then we should do it.
2 people like this
• Marikina, Philippines
28 Dec 12
Well, I've just ignore them. Maybe they have their own reason why they can't respond back or maybe they don't know what to respond. We really can't read their minds.
• India
28 Dec 12
Even I tend to ignore most of them and yes we can't read their mind on what they think and why they don't reply back but still I find it surprising and disappointing as well.
1 person likes this
@mariaperalta (19073)
• Mexico
28 Dec 12
I see that on mant people here, If you look I respond back to 99.9% of mine. I think its the right thing to do. If people take the time to read my posts and respond. I will for sure do the same after they have responded. Happy new years....
2 people like this
• India
28 Dec 12
Hi Maria, Yes, even I think the same way, I always try to respond to all the comments and that also helps me in earning here. It's easier to reply to a discussion which I've initiated rather than searching for an appropriate discussion. I don't know what people think or achieve by not replying in their own discussions. Thanks for your response!
1 person likes this
• India
28 Dec 12
I also observed some people just start a discussion and leave it on Auto Pilot mode and ran away.
2 people like this
• India
28 Dec 12
Ha ha ha..that's a good way of explaining it..it seems you've watched the last batman movie. To be frank, I don't like discussions initiated by Batmans here and that's why I've initiated this discussion to ask others what's their opinion on this.
• India
29 Dec 12
It's the last part of the this Batman series..
• India
29 Dec 12
LOL The Dark Knight is rising here in myLot.
1 person likes this
@ronnalee (43)
28 Dec 12
They do it to earn $$.
2 people like this
• India
28 Dec 12
Don't you earn while responding to your own discussions more than once?
• Valdosta, Georgia
29 Dec 12
You earn money by responding and having quality discussions...By not answering you earn nothing... You type you earn, I type I earn.
2 people like this
@Jennlee3 (292)
• United Kingdom
28 Dec 12
^^ only explanation.
2 people like this
@MsTickle (25180)
• Australia
31 Dec 12
I love your name for discussions abandoned by the original poster...good one! I must say though that I am surprised that this discussion is still here because it has been done many, many times. Don't be surprised if this gets deleted. Have you read the myLot Discussion Guidelines lately? I think it's a good idea if you refresh your memory of them: http://www.mylot.com/o/guidelines.aspx
1 person likes this
• India
31 Dec 12
Hi MsTickle, I don't see a reason for why this discussion should be deleted, have you ever heard of this name "Orphan discussions" before? Rather, I would be more than happy to see, myLot adding this name in their guidelines for such kind of discussions and make sure that people who initiate a discussion and don't even respond at least once should be warned. I'm here from last few years, though I don't come to myLot so often but I'm aware of the guideline rules, I've read them once again today and I don't see any reason for why this should be deleted. Often we feel something is right/wrong but we could also be wrong/right.
1 person likes this
@yoyo1198 (3641)
• United States
28 Dec 12
Once I find that the initiator isn't replying to their discussion, I avoid any of their ensuing discussions. It is just downright rude to ignore your responses. However, I do wait a day or two to see if they're going to get to them.
2 people like this
• India
28 Dec 12
Hi yoyo, Yes, it's kind of rude from their side to ignore the comments in their discussion. I agree that even I ignore a few comments in my discussion where I've no idea what to respond but I do try my best to reply to all the comments in my discussions. If I add a comment to any discussion, I do check back if someone has replied to my comment, just don't add a few word to any discussion, I add my opinion and I do expect others to share their point of view on that. Thanks for your response!
1 person likes this
@lampar (7584)
• United States
28 Dec 12
May be that person believe she can earn more dough by spending more of her time in initiating discussion topic than on commenting back to her responses, that is why showing very little interests to comment back, since her intention of mylotting is to earn as much money as possible through initiate discussion topic not about discussion itself. I will just avoid such type of member whenever possible, it is no point for me to respond and even read the discussion at all, i can spend my time in a better way.
2 people like this
• India
28 Dec 12
Hi lampar, Everyone of us have a mindset of earning online that's why we are here, if I respond to 10 different discussions or I respond to one discussion 10 times, I think both are same (Correct me if I'm wrong). If that's right then I don't get the point of not responding that too to a discussion which you've initiated with your own interest. Even I ignore such discussions where I don't see the initiator responding. Thanks for your response!
@rosekiss (30414)
• Eugene, Oregon
31 Dec 12
In order to earn, if the user doesn't repsond to their discussion,s then they don't ear anything, but then they probably think they don't have to do anything else, but just start a discussion, and others will take care of the rest. I agree with you, that if users are going to start discussions, they should at least be considerate of others, and respond back. they are just being lazy for the most part, and they probably also start as many discussions a they can, in one day, and don't respond to any of them. I always make a point to repond to all my discussions, as that is the right thing to do. i know, I wo't earn unless i do either. Take care, and have fun mylotting.
• India
31 Dec 12
Hi rosekiss, That's true, if they are not aware of the myLot rules, they might end up making such mistake. I often get annoyed of people who initiate more than 5 discussion in one day, there were instances when I had to delete a few friends from list for initiating several discussions in one day and obviously most of those discussions will be of no use. Hope this discussion will be of some use here on this website.
1 person likes this
@roshigo58 (4859)
• Pune, India
28 Dec 12
I have not noticed so far this type of attitude from my friends. I do respond to all the discussions i have initiated. This is the right way of sharing and gathering the friends. All is in vein if it is not followed. I do agree with you.
2 people like this
• India
28 Dec 12
Good for you that you have never come across such discussion, however, if you ask others, everyone of us had come across some discussions and it actually helps no one. Thanks for your response, roshigo58!
@deazil (4730)
• United States
1 Jan 13
This has been a bone of contention with some members for a long time. It gets brought up every so often. But I've never heard them called "orphan discussions" and I think that's a perfect name for them! I've heard of the "disappearing authors" or "absentee discussion starters". Some people don't care if the author doesn't comment. There are some reasons why as mentioned in other responses. For me, I think it's rude. A lot of times I research stuff and provide links. And then no comment, nothing. I don't usually respond again to those authors. There are plenty of discussions to respond to where I will get a comment and even some good back and forth conversations. People don't realize that's what mylot likes to see, I think. The days when I have those conversations with people that take up the whole page are when my earnings are the highest. When I get comments I usually go back and further the discussion. Not everybody comes back to carry it on, but that's okay. I'm just enjoying myself here. Mylot is my escape.
1 person likes this
• India
1 Jan 13
Hi deazil, Before initiating any discussion I do search in the myLot search bar and if I don't fine related discussions then only I initiate a new discussion, however, as you said, no one has ever come up with a suitable name for such discussions, if that's the case, I think this discussion is unique among all the discussions here on myLot. As far as getting response in a discussion is concerned, as you can see, I try my best to reply to all the comments that I get in my discussions, this solves the purpose of initiating a discussion and at the same time I get paid. I've no clue, neither does anyone else among 18 people who have replied here in this discussion have any clue about why do people just initiate a discussion and then don't reply. I agree to the fact that the initiator of the discussion sometimes gets delayed in replying, even I get delayed if I'm busy in my daily life but I make sure that I reply to all the comments that I get in my discussions and it's actually easier that finding a new discussion, reading the comments and then responding. Hope we'll see less number of Orphan discussions here on myLot. Thanks for your response!
1 person likes this
• India
1 Jan 13
Hi deazil, If you go by the myLot guidelines, you are not supposed to add a URL of another discussion to any of the discussions. However, as you said, it's the way we discussion that also matters, blindly they won't delete any discussion if there is a little bit of similarity of the content and I feel myLot admin should use this new term in the guidelines and they should come up with new rules for such orphan discussions. Thanks for your response!
1 person likes this
@deazil (4730)
• United States
1 Jan 13
You know, now that you mention it, I realized none of the other discussions about this got deleted. So it must be a certain time limit or how the topic is presented that makes the difference. Or, it's just another one of the mysteries of mylot. And like you said, there's no mention of "orphan discussions". I think you've coined a new phrase. One reason for not commenting back is a lot of new users. They think by creating lots of discussions they'll earn a ton of money. I have done a mylot search and can only find one discussion regarding this issue. I know I responded to 2 and have seen others, but longer ago than this one. It's here if you're interested: www.mylot.com/w/discussions/2714825.aspx And I had trouble finding this one. There are old ones from 4-5 years ago.
1 person likes this
@Shavkat (140119)
• Philippines
28 Dec 12
I do think that all the members have different time zones, some may not have the time to wait. They need to sleep and find time to reply on the following day or so. But then, some of them are working.
• India
28 Dec 12
Yes, that's a good point Shavkat. Even in this discussion, it took time for me to reply back but within one day you see my response on this page, I was talking about those discussions where the user is active and is responding to other discussions but due to some reasons not finding time to reply back in his/her own discussions. I remember once I had initiated a discussion where I could reply back only after a week but I did reply to the comments, though not to all of them.
1 person likes this
• India
28 Dec 12
I agree i too have seen such discussions here . I didn't understand whether to respond them or not . Though i am not very active here i come here once in a while when i have time. The reason why i didn't initiate discussions is that i dont get that much time so i stick to giving responses to others discussions i think thats better . If i start any discussions i dont like to leave it without giving responses i feel something incomplete so better not to start any .
2 people like this
• India
28 Dec 12
Even I'm not always active here on myLot and it's not that easy for me to initiate a discussion. Until I find something really necessary, I don't initiate a discussion. Like you, even I prefer responding to other discussions but I get disappointed when I get no response of my comment.
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
29 Dec 12
hi dollar this is one thing that really gets to m e when I write a response from my heart and the poster does not comment back or just says thanks which incidentally will not be paid by admins if you thank some one make it part of a comment, and not just alone. its rude to me as I spent time responding hoping to get the poster's comment back and see the discussion take off.I have never written a discussion without really trying my best to comment back to all the responses I got. Sometimes if I have a lot of responses I may take several days but I will do my best to comment back on all responses.
• India
29 Dec 12
Hi Hatley, That's true, though we are here to earn money but that doesn't mean we just type something or respond like bots. Those response are still fine to some extent, when I see that the discussion initiator has completely abandoned the discussion after initiating I really wonder why was it initiate at the first place if s/he was not willing to share his/her opinion on this topic. I think it's the lack of understanding of myLot rules, it seems most of the users here think that they get paid only if the number in front of our user name increases, that's why they respond to a discussion only once which I'm sure is not true. Let's hope a few of them go through this discussion and understand the actual rule and start behaving as more responsible myLot user. Thanks for your response, Hatley!
1 person likes this
@Hatley (163776)
• Garden Grove, California
15 Jan 13
hi dollar no I sure have not nor will I ever do such a thing. I try my best to comment back as soon as I can after posting my discussion as I know its both rude not to and also it does not open up my discussion to being a real discussion until we have input from others and then input from ourselves to the others. It take two to tango and also to make a discussion into a real discussion.I like the term orphan discussions because that is sort of what they are.
• India
15 Jan 13
Hi Hatley, Nice to see your response in this discussion, to be frank, it's one of the annoying thing here on myLot and yes, I agree there are times when I don't respond to comments in my own discussion and that's because of time. For me myLot is a place to meet my friends and to enjoy my time, it's much better than Facebook. Still I know it's my responsibility to get back to those who have shared their opinion in my discussions. Good to know that you liked the name of such discussions. Thanks for your response!
• India
15 Jan 13
I'm sorry for any confusion, I meant, orphan discussions are the annoying thing here on myLot. Note: English is not my first language.
• India
20 Feb 13
Yes you are right, many such discussions exist, even i have some still to comment back on the responses.
• India
20 Feb 13
Hi Professor ji! Even I agree that I can't respond to each and every comment in my discussions or in any other discussion where I add my comment, however, I always try my best to respond to comments. I can assure you that if I initiate any discussion, it'll never be an orphan discussion.
@inertia4 (27960)
• United States
13 Jan 13
I have never done that. I can tell you this though, there have been times when I never got any email notifications on any responses I had gotten on one the discussions I have created. But I do go into them from time to time to see if there are any new responses. However, I have been having an issue where as I am not getting my earnings updated daily. It seems that whatever I did yesterday I have not received an earnings update today. I used to get updated around 10 in the morning, then it went to 11, then it was around 12. And then the problem started. I started seeing my earnings update happening around 8 at night. Now it has not been updated at all. Maybe its me. But that is an example as to why some discussions go un-responded. Mainly like I said, no email notifications and laziness on behalf of the creator of the discussion. So all things being equal, there are always glitches and that could cause some of the problem.
• India
15 Jan 13
Hi inertia4, I'm sorry for the delayed response. Yes, I know, you always respond to your comments in all your discussion, whether your initiate it or your add a comment to some discussion and we've discussed on different topics. It's really nice see people like you who take it as responsibility to get back to all those who take their time in responding to your comments. Laziness, I would say is the main factor in these discussions, even sometimes, I get so lazy that I don't feel like responding to discussions but sooner or later, I do respond to the comments in my discussions. As far as earning updation timings are concerned, I've really never checked at what time it gets updated but there doesn't seem to be any issue with the earning updation in my account. Let's hope once in my life, I get a payout from myLot. Thanks for your response, intertia4
1 person likes this
• India
26 Jan 13
That could be possible because maintaining a website like myLot is not that easy. If you ask me, I don't even remember which e-mail id I used to logging into this website. I'm dependent on the tabs which are listed at the top of this page under the search bar. (today's top, my interests, new, recent, started, responded, friends started etc..) I refer to those tabs and see if anyone has replied to my discussions or to my comments in other discussions.
@inertia4 (27960)
• United States
26 Jan 13
Thank you. I also see you respond to many discussions as well. But I will say this, for the last 3 to 4 days now I have not been getting any of my email notifications from MyLot. They must be having another problem. I did send them an email, but never got a response. This has happened to me a few times in the past. I don't know why this happens, but it happens. So some of the discussions I might not see the response from. But I would have to take more time and go into each and everyone of them on the site itself.
@roshigo58 (4859)
• Pune, India
2 Mar 13
Hi, The name given by you to the discussions which have no response is very perfect. I always give responses to the discussions with zero response discussions daily. I also respond back for the comment of my discussions.
• India
4 Mar 13
Hi roshigo58, I'm glad to know that the word fits perfectly for such kind of discussions. It's good for everyone when someone responds to the comments in their discussions. That's the proper/right way of being here on myLot. Keep it up !!! Thanks for your response, roshigo58!