Is it worth posting on controversial topics?
@sprite1950 (30452)
Corsham, England
March 24, 2018 2:58am CST
I have made a conscious decision to stay away from topics like religion (especially religion), politics and any other discussions that might cause arguments.
MyLot is a really nice place to post .. until one of these subjects rears it's head and then everything changes. These topics have even been the cause of people leaving the site.
Do you post on controversial topics or do you leave well alone?
Image from Pixabay
28 people like this
34 responses
@sprite1950 (30452)
• Corsham, England
24 Mar 18
I'm an easy going person and of course I have my views like everyone else but I don't want to fall out with people.
3 people like this
@sprite1950 (30452)
• Corsham, England
24 Mar 18
@LadyDuck I do. As soon as someone starts quoting from the bible I'm gone.
4 people like this
@LadyDuck (471253)
• Switzerland
24 Mar 18
@sprite1950 I have seen some users really fight for religion here. Better to skip that topic.
3 people like this
@sprite1950 (30452)
• Corsham, England
24 Mar 18
Some people seem to thrive on these discussions but the arguments get so heated and in the light of someone leaving MyLot over religion recently I think you are right. There should be a site purely for these topics.
4 people like this
@vandana7 (100214)
• India
24 Mar 18
Attacking is oh so wrong! I always gave myLot a higher ranking when compared to other social media sites such as facebook because we can interact at intellectual levels here and grow as persons, with our respective experiences, knowledge, etc. In ancient days they had Roman elders or was it Greek elders sitting together and discussing various problems. myLot in some way seems of that caliber and is not merely earning site. In fact earnings here are negligible.
6 people like this
@MALUSE (69373)
• Germany
24 Mar 18
@vandana7 Did you have pink glasses on your nose when you were writing this? My view of the site is not so positive.
"we can interact at intellectual levels here and grow as persons, with our respective experiences, knowledge, etc" We can or rather we could. I doubt that we do.
2 people like this
@sprite1950 (30452)
• Corsham, England
24 Mar 18
I feel exactly the same. It can be upsetting if someone is rude.
4 people like this
@vandana7 (100214)
• India
24 Mar 18
I often do. I think controversies are for keeping brain active. There are two ways of living. One is doing it mechanically, and other is understanding the principle of why we do what we do. When we are young, we are fairly busy so accepting many things mechanically comes easily, and is also the need of the hour as we are working and should not disturb ourselves. But when we still have some thoughts later on, why not?
6 people like this
@vandana7 (100214)
• India
24 Mar 18
@sprite1950 Unpleasantness is because people word it wrongly. I have had good heated debates and no harsh words were exchanged with many people who have continued to be my friends.
I will give you an example. I had long ago taken a stand that Hitler was not directly responsible for final solution (because Newsweek magazine some 30 odd years ago had mentioned there was no evidence linking him). I have argued, and most people accepted he was guilty. I needed the "missing link"...believe me at least 4 posts ...nobody came to remove my ignorance. It is only in the 3rd post that I read something which made me read more and more and finally I came to logical conclusion. I need to be convinced. If I am not convinced, I can't take sides.
1 person likes this
@sprite1950 (30452)
• Corsham, England
24 Mar 18
@vandana7 You have a very logical way of looking at things but not everyone is like that unfortunately.
3 people like this
@sprite1950 (30452)
• Corsham, England
24 Mar 18
I suppose so but I've seen a bit of unpleasantness here when it comes to discussing them and that puts me off.
3 people like this
@topffer (42156)
• France
24 Mar 18
@sprite1950 Your choice, and it is not a bad choice as I have noticed that discussions about politics and religion are getting usually less responses.
3 people like this
@sprite1950 (30452)
• Corsham, England
24 Mar 18
That's true but I know what it feels like to be bashed on an online site and I don't want to feel like that again. Easy going discussions for me these days.
3 people like this
@Daljinder (23236)
• Bangalore, India
24 Mar 18
I don't go hunting for such posts but I don't shy away from them either. I am more about learning and exploring to feed my brain. Gives my brain exercise as well and keeps things interesting. Why should I stop learning, exploring or doing things that interest me just because there are people who have a problem keeping an open mind and can turn any discussion into an argument? LOL!
I have been called names many times by such people. I can handle that and if worse came to worst I can always report or block them.
I haven't done any post on religion yet. It's been 2 years since I am here. Maybe someday if I feel the need to.
5 people like this
@sprite1950 (30452)
• Corsham, England
24 Mar 18
@vandana7 Your knight in shining armour
3 people like this
@sprite1950 (30452)
• Corsham, England
24 Mar 18
That's a good attitude to have. I'm probably a little oversensitive and need to toughen up. Until then I shall stick to friendly discussions where I know people won't want to argue with me.
4 people like this
@sprite1950 (30452)
• Corsham, England
24 Mar 18
Indeed. I have noticed that since l came here
2 people like this
@sprite1950 (30452)
• Corsham, England
25 Mar 18
@pgntwo Thanks .. looks like me on a bad day!
2 people like this
@pgntwo (22408)
• Derry, Northern Ireland
24 Mar 18
@sprite1950 Love the Alice in Wonderland reference in your photo!
"Off with her head!".
2 people like this
@sprite1950 (30452)
• Corsham, England
24 Mar 18
I've noticed that there are times when that's difficult but for the most part this is a friendly place.
2 people like this
@TheHorse (218450)
• Walnut Creek, California
24 Mar 18
@sprite1950 Yes. Most of us can even disagree about a topic and still discuss it without becoming uncivil.
2 people like this
@vandana7 (100214)
• India
25 Mar 18
Exactly ..it should not be my way or the highway. It should be a process that helps us to understand each other. Agreed based on our personal experiences we would be inclined to hold on more firmly to a stand that we have arrived. But here, I learned that not every drunkard's family is ungrateful.
3 people like this
@sprite1950 (30452)
• Corsham, England
25 Mar 18
Yes, sometimes people cannot think outside the box and then it will cause arguments.
3 people like this
@sprite1950 (30452)
• Corsham, England
24 Mar 18
Probably because you were quite new. People don't like change. At least you didn't let it put you off coming here.
1 person likes this
@NoorNoor (2131)
• India
24 Mar 18
Politics and religion are just a topic to me.If anyone doesn't want to comment those they will just skip.but people make big deal to this.Here we have rights to post until we harm or hurt others. The world is running because of those topics so no problem to talk about those and get some knowledge.Some people just want to know other religion's practices.This is my opinion.
3 people like this
@sprite1950 (30452)
• Corsham, England
24 Mar 18
It rarely stops at that though. because some don't respect the views of others. Perhaps there should be a special section here for controversial topics.
3 people like this
@NoorNoor (2131)
• India
24 Mar 18
@sprite1950 yes of course.and i know my limits too.
3 people like this
@vandana7 (100214)
• India
24 Mar 18
@sprite1950 I agree..it doesn't stop there. But we need to develop a more tolerant language and way to understand each other. Ability to respect? Isn't the absence of it the cause of all problems humans face? So if there is a chance to develop that ability, why not?
3 people like this
@sprite1950 (30452)
• Corsham, England
24 Mar 18
I'm not either but sometimes people try to draw you into a discussion about another subject and then bring religion into it.
2 people like this
@Starmaiden (9311)
• Canada
24 Mar 18
I never post a discussion on controversial topics although I've posted a few opinions on others.
:-)
4 people like this
@sprite1950 (30452)
• Corsham, England
24 Mar 18
Well it's the opinions that seem to cause the problems. If I can see someone challenging me I usually say I given my views and have nothing more to say, then leave the discussion.
2 people like this
@GardenGerty (160600)
• United States
24 Mar 18
I am here for fun and socializing and uplifting, so I tend to avoid battles and controversy. I will converse about faith and religion, but I will not fight about it or call names if someone believes differently than I do.
2 people like this
@snowy22315 (180337)
• United States
25 Mar 18
I have done it, and I will say, I usually regret it when I do. Some people whether they mean to be or not, are just insulting.
2 people like this
@sprite1950 (30452)
• Corsham, England
25 Mar 18
Yes I have so regretted making certain comments not so much here but on other forums
1 person likes this
@cmoneyspinner (9219)
• Austin, Texas
25 Mar 18
Define "controversial". What may upset one person may roll like water off a duck's back for another person? If I have something I want to discuss I start the discussion. If other people also want to discuss that's great! Otherwise, it's just me talking to myself and that's fine too. As long as I'm following the site's rules for content and courtesy, I'm not leaving!
2 people like this
@sprite1950 (30452)
• Corsham, England
28 Mar 18
@cmoneyspinner Yes I saw it but I haven't left a comment. I can understand that we should play nicely though.
2 people like this
@sprite1950 (30452)
• Corsham, England
25 Mar 18
@cmoneyspinner Hello you .. you're going to get a ban for this comment on FC
Controversial .. a subject likely to cause public disagreement with many differing views .. like religion. People get heated when discussing this topic because there are so many different religions and each person thinks his is the true one. Also atheists and agnostics will often give their view which can upset some people.
2 people like this
@cmoneyspinner (9219)
• Austin, Texas
28 Mar 18
@sprite1950 - I just signed in today and see that the Administrator has written a long post about "censorship". Here I was thinking about controversy when I should have been concerning myself with censorship.
2 people like this
@sallypup (60933)
• Centralia, Washington
24 Mar 18
There are so many kinds of religions. Its easy to offend someone there. And food. I run toward eating clean; little processed fake food for me and that can get the Mac N Cheese crowd irritated if I talk too much about vegetarianism.
2 people like this
@sprite1950 (30452)
• Corsham, England
24 Mar 18
I don't think veggie talk would irritate me too much although I'm not vegetarian myself.
2 people like this
@sprite1950 (30452)
• Corsham, England
25 Mar 18
I definitely like a quieter life
2 people like this
@anikoonline (3250)
• Hungary
24 Mar 18
I don't like controversial topics (mostly politics and religion). I don't comment on these post and I don't talk about it in my offline life except for a few very close friends. They are private topics that need to be respected and there's no meaning of arguing about these.
2 people like this
@sprite1950 (30452)
• Corsham, England
24 Mar 18
@anikoonline Some people will try to bring religion into a discussion that has nothing to do with it though and I think that's where the problems start.
2 people like this
@sprite1950 (30452)
• Corsham, England
24 Mar 18
@anikoonline If only everyone saw it that way but they don't.
2 people like this
@anikoonline (3250)
• Hungary
24 Mar 18
@sprite1950 Yes, I think that religion is someone's personal confidence. I think that we should not convince anyone of our personal belief. It is rather should be about acceptance of the difference in religion and faith.
2 people like this